How to select non-shedding dog breeds; a beginner's hub for dog lovers prone to allergies

82

By Storytellersrus

Finnegan loves Annie, but spaniels shed.
See all 3 photos
Finnegan loves Annie, but spaniels shed.
Source: JSS
The balance in our family went askew when sweet Lorraine died.
The balance in our family went askew when sweet Lorraine died.
Source: JSS

Our elder poodle died of kidney failure on Election Day, leaving Finnegan, an Irish soft-coated wheaten terrier, without a fuzzy companion to annoy. I was in mourning and uncertain whether to add another household pet until Finn fell into a bit of a depression; wheatens are very social dogs and though we walk our two year old twice daily, he needs more action than my husband and I are able to provide.

The immediate question became, what type of dog will provide Finnegan with needed play, while suiting the needs of those who frequent our home, i.e., our son has allergies; some day we hope to have grandchildren; we have one barking dog, do we need another, etc.

I found several sites offering pet quizes, and took them all. I was uncertain regarding my doggie priorities until I examined the dogs recommended on these sites. Most sites did not have a category for hypoallergenic, as it is considered highly unpredictable to claim a dog does not produce dander and therefore will not cause an allergic person to sneeze. However, one did ask whether or not we wanted a dog to shed and the second I listed below actually separated dogs immediately into purebred or hybrid categories, which was most valuable.

Hybrid dogs

Hybrid dogs are sometimes called Designer Dogs and can be very expensive. If money is an object, there are always Rescue Dogs and Adopt a Dog groups to research. I found myself leaning towards labradoodles and visited a local litter raised by a sweet elderly gentleman. His puppies did not have wavy hair, generally indicative of a non-shedder, but they were adorable and so very loved. I found myself wanting to carry every one of his three puppies home to Finnegan!

I resisted.  Do you know how difficult it is to resist a puppy face?  I returned home to research the shedding possibilities of this combination dog. I discovered a hybrid dog like a labradoodle- born of a Labrador Retriever and a Poodle- might shed depending on the purebred or hybrid status of its parents. There are evidently four categories of labradoodles that define such a status.

If one parent is pure lab and the other pure poodle, this is considered a first generation hybrid. But if one of the parents is already a Labradoodle and has been bred with a purebred poodle, this becomes what is called an F1B hybrid. This is the type least likely to shed.

To understand hybrids and categories of hybrids, please click on the links below.

What do I do now???

I discovered, through research, that the litter of labradoodles I fell in love with does not fit the categories described in the link above. The mother of this litter is First Generation, with a poodle mom and a lab retriever dad.

BUT the sweet elderly gentleman bred her with a lab and not a poodle! This means they are not F1B hybrids, but some sort of lab leaning hybrid, which means they will be more likely to shed. Oh woe! I cannot have a shedding dog in this household or my son will never come visit.

Now I must call and tell this breeder that I cannot purchase his puppy after all. Sad.  I must believe there is a proper home out for his three adorable pups; a home where there are hunters who want the poodle brain and the lab brain- both these breeds are high on the list of intelligent dogs.  I am not of that ilk.

I went to the link below and applied, instead, to adopt a Doodle. In the process, I discovered that there are mini- labradoodles!  Breeders have bred miniature poodles to Labrador retrievers and even bred labs to toy poodles! My curiosity has been tweaked.

I am astonished when further research reveals a Labradoodle Ranch only miles from my house. I have written for an invitation to visit and plan to check it all out when frigid outside temperatures ease.

Drat, I must make that dreadful telephone call...  Truth be told, it is best to be honest with myself and to find the dog suiting my household needs.  Rescue dogs are numerous.  I do not wish to be one of those sad owners who must give up a pet due to allergies, or suffer the runny nose consequences.  I hope my adventure has helped narrow your search for the dog best suited to your lifestyle.

Good luck!

I give you until Spring to find me a friend, Mom.  After that, my patience will run out!
I give you until Spring to find me a friend, Mom. After that, my patience will run out!
Source: JSS

The end of the story.

I wound up with a goldendoodle, on my way to purchasing a labradoodle. I could have gone either way- the breeder was conducting a fire sale of sorts and both were suddenly in my price range.

My daughter and I preferred the curly coat on the goldendoodle and he seemed to be possessive of us, as all the puppies bounced over our laps and around their cozy barn. We could have been satisfied with either, I'm sure, but I have grown more and more fond of the gentle yet determined personality of our Baxter Thor (a combination of my daughter's name choice and mine). Yes, perhaps it is pretentious to have a dog with two names, but its descriptive; at 9 months, BT has the sweet puppy nature of a Baxter, but the 80 pound bulk of a Thor!

I need to warn readers regarding wheatens, however.

Finnegan has had severe issues with skin itching and requires a raw meat diet, which is expensive. Turns out Irish Soft-coated Wheaten Terriers were overbred in the United States and the locally born litters are all too often a mess.

If you are interested in this wonderful breed- their intense eyes and focused intelligence- please check out the breeder and make certain you are not getting a dog from a puppy mill or an uninformed basement breeder. The best wheatens are those that come from Ireland, where the breed has been carefully tracked- or from established breeders in the US who are not afraid to discuss this issue with you and to point out the facts.

Comments

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus Hub Author 6 months ago

Thank you jesusmyjoy. What kind of dog do you have? I will check out your profile, perhaps there I will find out why you enjoyed this hub!

jesusmyjoy profile image

jesusmyjoy 6 months ago

this is great

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus Hub Author 15 months ago

Jaspal, I wonder that you make due with so many cocker spaniels in a flat. But you are an amazing sort of fellow, even if you do make me laugh... or maybe because you can make me laugh!!!

Jaspal profile image

Jaspal Level 1 Commenter 15 months ago

I again forgot to mention ... I love the pics here. They're so full of love and positive energy.

Jaspal profile image

Jaspal Level 1 Commenter 15 months ago

Oh, lolol ... thank you Story ... sometimes it takes a bit of hammering to illumine me!! Hugs for you too. :)

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus Hub Author 15 months ago

Um yes, Jaspal, I like hair! LOL. I will pass on the hairless. I loved my cocker spaniel, too. But there are dogs evidently, who do not have undercoats. This helps their dander. Hugs, friend!

Jaspal profile image

Jaspal Level 1 Commenter 15 months ago

Great hub! There are so many friends and relatives who love dogs but just cannot keep one due to their allergies. All dogs shed - some more, some less - excepting maybe a completely hairless dog like the American Hairless Terrier. Check him out here: http://www.dogbreedinfo.com/americanhairlessterrie

I love dogs, and often wish I was living somewhere in the countryside where one could afford a big bungalow or farmhouse and have many dogs and maybe some horses too! But living in a flat in Delhi, one makes do with cocker spaniels. When it comes to shedding, they're probably the worst. I cannot ever seem to be able to get their hair out of my suits and jackets!

Ari Lamstein profile image

Ari Lamstein 15 months ago

This is a great Hub. I love dogs, and would like to adopt one. However, I have held off due to my allergy. This Hub really helps me a lot.

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus Hub Author 15 months ago

Jazzi, I would miss a lot if I was offended by strong wording! Thanks again for the additional advice you have provided, obviously based on experience.

Alexander, I wish you the best of luck finding a furry friend. They are great companions- I have one sprawled across my reference book as we speak. And another peering over the rail begging, "Walk me! The sun is getting low on the horizon!"

Alexander Mark profile image

Alexander Mark Level 6 Commenter 15 months ago

What a wonderful rescue story. And bless you for being willing to compromise. When the time comes, I certainly will call around - you never know.

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus Hub Author 15 months ago

Alexander, I had a good experience with the first dog I got at the pound. I wanted to get my husband a schnauzer, as he had loved his childhood pet. I called a local rescue dog agency and they said it was very rare to find a schnauzer, but they would put me on a list.

That very afternoon they called me and asked if I could race over to a local pound where a schnauzer was rumored to be on death row. I went with a friend and, though the scruffy dog looked nothing like a schnauzer, brought him home because his energy was so happy and well, he was adorable.

Two days later, I took him to a groomer to clean up his coat. I suggested a schnauzer cut and low and behold, when I came to pick him up, I didn't even recognize him. Turned out he was pure schnauzer! We called him Schweitzer and loved him for another ten years.

My advice is call around! You never know!

Alexander Mark profile image

Alexander Mark Level 6 Commenter 15 months ago

It's amazing that breeding can be refined to the point that you will be able to determine whether the offspring are shedding or non-shedding. I wonder how likely it is to find a mixed breed dog of my choice at a shelter? I always figured that I would go to a shelter to get my next dog and hope to find some kind of border collie mix with gentle character traits. I was friends with one once and it was a complete lap dog.

Jazzi480 profile image

Jazzi480 15 months ago

Glad you thought so! Sometimes I am tooo strong in my wording, but too many people buy into the myth that crossbreds are healthier. The truth of the matter is breeds share many of the exact same genetic issues, and without knowing what they are or if the dam and sire have them or carriers the "breeder" is playing with fire. If you are looking for a allergy friendly dog look to not only low shedding but low dander. I had a Golden/Samoyed mix that went blind at age 2 because of PRA. Both parents have to be carriers to produce the disease. If there is no knowledge of the parents then anything can turn up no matter what breed or cross. That is why I recomend a real reputable breeder that does testing and trully working to improve their chosen breed.

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus Hub Author 15 months ago

Jazzi, excellent point! Designer Dogs also have health issues, though because they are not purebred, the issues tend to be more diluted.

It is always good to know what you are buying. We had a scare with our adopted wheaten, because American wheatens have been bred so tight, they have a tendency to inherit a problem absorbing protein and many die by age 5 or 6. Obviously when you love a dog, the idea of it dying at such a young age is extremely painful.

It makes great sense to figure out what you want and then learn as much as possible about the breed, mutt or otherwise. Thanks.

Jazzi480 profile image

Jazzi480 15 months ago

What no one seems to whant to talk about is health testing on these so called breeds. Mutts and crosses have been around for years, but now people are willing to pay rediculous amounts of money for crossbred dogs that can be rescued from the nearest shelter or pound. If you have specific needs then buy a purebred from a REPUTABLE breeder who does ALL available health testing, temparment testing ect! If you notice most designer, crossbreds are some type of poodle cross, there is a reason for this. Poodles are top in intelligence, non shedding,ect. The video you post says nothing of genetic problems of any of these "breeds" only about cutness. Many breeds share the same genetic issues, such as PRA, Hip Dispaysia,Bloat and list goes on. Just because you cross two breeds does not mean you will have a healthy puppy. If you want a non-shedding dog then research those breeds as there are many. If you just want cute with no reguard to breeding or health then adopt from the nearest pound. If you are willing to pay hundreds, thousands of dollars for a mutt then there are hundreds of so called breeders willing to sell you one.

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus Hub Author 15 months ago

Mr. Happy, I love that you are so knowledgeable about dogs! I am going to have to peruse your hubs and find the ones relevant to my cause. I am surprised to learn dobermans do not shed much. I thought they shed short, bristly hairs. We had three schnauzers and the last one broke the mold; whenever I look at a litter, I find myself unconsciously looking for another Herschel. I did think of a schnoodle, lol. They are adorable and smart.

Eiddwen, I enjoyed observing all the dogs in the Designer Dog video, as well as a bit of history about the evolution of these dogs... and the Australian accent charms me, truth be told. I do love an accent. Thanks for commenting!

da, I have read so much about shelter dogs and their need for good homes. It is a quandry, in a way; if I don't get a puppy, perhaps casual breeders will stop breeding their dogs. But then again, if I do get a puppy and create a good home for it, well, that is one less dog on the street. We found our first schnauzer at the pound on death row. In fact, of five dogs, only two have been purchased as puppies. With our allergy requirements, it is challenging to find dogs in shelters, which is why I was so excited to find the Doodle Adoption Agency linked above. Keep up the great work, loving your pups!

dahoglund profile image

dahoglund Level 7 Commenter 15 months ago

Although I don't have dog allergies i have found an allergic reaction to some things can be downright dangerous. We have had resccue or dogs from the dog shelters for the last 30 years or so mainly because we hope to keep one dog at a time from being without a home.

Eiddwen profile image

Eiddwen 15 months ago

Thanks for this great read. I in my time have had two Doberman and a Schnauzer!! The Doberman as MR Happy pointed out do not lose much hair while the Schnauzer didn't lose any but had to be regularly groomed or the coat would matt.

I also loved the video clip and that Pugalier was gorgeous.

Thanks for sharing this

Take care

Eiddwen

Mr. Happy profile image

Mr. Happy Level 7 Commenter 15 months ago

Hey Storyteller,

I owned a dog, worked with dogs and trained dogs. I can try to answer questions regarding our furry friends. In respect to non-shedding dogs, obviously the ones with short hair are the best.

A Rottweiler, Great Dane or a Doberman will not leave much hair around because they barely have any. Yet, there are dogs with longer hair which do not shed much. I owned an Airedale Terrier for fourteen years and I never had many problems with her hair (of course brushing your dog regularly also helps, in many ways). Terriers have a wire type of hair, much thicker than your regular dog's hair; it doesn't fall out as much in comparison to that of a German Sheppard, Collie or any other long-haired dogs which have the thin, smooth hair sort of coat.

Look into Schnauzers as well, same sort of wired-hair and they come in different sizes: Mini Schnauzer and the regular giant kind lol.

There are literally hundreds of breeds of dogs. Take your time and good luck!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working